reseize logo;

Who is what? What is where? Where am I? Are you there?

You have hit the other collection, a newslog designed for the curious.

reseize web
  • Netvibes
  • Writely
  • Bubbleshare
  • CalendarHub
  • Rallypoint
  • MyLinkVault bookmarking service
  • YubNub
  • Techcrunch Blog
  • The best Web 2.0 software
  • Blog Directory
  • Videolan
  • Open Office
  • Mozilla
  • Hazard Cards
  • kei-koo
  • Laboranova
  • Ajax by Joel Parish
  • The grand old dame of social tags ;-)
  • another bid on social bookmarking
  • Kaspersky
  • MediaMonkey
  • Flock
  • Google Blog
  • Google News

  • Powered by FeedBlitz

  • Home of Radi8
  • Radi8 at Garageband
  • Terminator Ted at Garageband
  • Coralie at Garageband
  • Radi8 at CD Baby
  • OpenWengo
  • VOIP Now
  • VOIP News
  • VOIP
  • VOIP
  • Skype
  • Google Talk
  • Free CA - by Barmala
  • Web Of Trust auch auf Deutsch
  • The Minstrel web of trust
  • Thawte Web Of Trust
  • 10 Punkte Web Of Trust Notar
  • Boing Boing
  • Engadget
  • Basenotes
  • Radi8 Mirror
  • Orkut
  • Blogarama
    Subscribe in Bloglines

    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    Add to Google

    Subscribe in FeedLounge

    Add to My AOL

    Subscribe in Rojo

    Friday, February 10, 2006

    Tom Bethell, the Odd Duck Anti-Evolutioniston on AIDS -- The Breakdown

    Chris has been excoriating Tom Bethell (author of "The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science") over on The Intersection and elsewhere (see, for example, here, here, and several posts here). However, since he's not yet done a takedown on Bethell's chaper on AIDS (titled "African AIDS: a Political Epidemic"), he suggested I have a go at it. Man, I knew the book would be bad, but it reaches a whole new level of terrible.
    Bethell's central thesis will be familiar to anyone who's read the anti-HIV arguments by Peter Duesberg and others. As the chapter title suggests, Bethell claims that AIDS in Africa is a made-up epidemic; AIDS is really due to simple malnutrition and dirty water supplies, rather than a virus. Government officials, scientists, and journalists are either too brainwashed or too scared to speak against the "AIDS orthodoxy." The evil liberals aren't concerned about AIDS because the real concern of the left, according to Bethell, is overpopulation in Africa (and hence the emphasis on condom use to prevent AIDS). Public health officials aren't actually concerned about disease in Africa--just overpopulation. Little did I know.
    However, Bethell's story is long on emotion and hyperbole, and short on facts. His references read like a report I wrote in my 9th grade English class: newspapers, a few books, magazines (heavy-hitters like Rolling Stone and SPIN), and a grand total of 2 references from science journals. Really, he should leave off the "Politically" portion of the title--the Incorrect Guide to Science is much more apt.
    Okay, okay. Enough snark. (C'mon, reading this was 20 minutes of my life I'll never get back--I think I'm entitled to some seething). So, on to address Bethell's claims.
    Get the whole article posted by John Farrell at AETIOLOGY

    Comments on "Tom Bethell, the Odd Duck Anti-Evolutioniston on AIDS -- The Breakdown"


    post a comment

    Links to "Tom Bethell, the Odd Duck Anti-Evolutioniston on AIDS -- The Breakdown"

    Create a Link